Conservative or liberal news and updates
For the best conservative news for conservatives, check out ConservativeVoice.tv. And if you want great liberal and progressive news for liberals and progressives, look for LiberalVoice.tv.
A man was sentenced to death instead of prison because he’s gay, Supreme Court refused to intervene
Posted on June 25, 2018 at 5:20 PM
Where there’s evidence that racial bias affected a jury outcome, the Supreme Court now sends criminal cases back for reconsideration. As Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in one such case, the “law punishes people for what they do, not who they are.” But in a recent appeal based on evidence of anti-gay bias, the Supreme Court took a pass.
In 1993, a South Dakota jury convicted Charles Rhines of stabbing another man, Donnivan Schaeffer, to death during a robbery. They sentenced him to death for the crime only after asking the judge what life in prison would be like for Rhines.
Their handwritten note had a not-so-subtle motivation:
If they didn’t vote for the death penalty, what would his life in prison look like? Would he be “allowed to mix with the general inmate population”? Would he be able “to create a group of followers or admirers”? Would he have a cellmate?
Jurors also asked if Rhines would be able to “brag” to “young men” or have conjugal visits.
Because Rhines is gay, jurors reasoned, he’d probably enjoy prison. After the judge replied that he couldn’t answer their questions, the jury opted for death rather than life in prison.
“There was lots of discussion of homosexuality,” one juror recalled, according to affidavits later filed in court. “There were lots of folks who were like, ‘Ew, I can’t believe that.’” Another juror said they “knew that he was a homosexual and thought that he shouldn’t be able to spend his life with men in prison.” A third recalled overhearing a fellow juror say that life in prison would mean “sending him where he wants to go.”
In an affidavit, one juror even admitted that knowledge of Rhines’ sexual orientation swayed his decision.